Frequently Asked Questions
Managing people comes with plenty of questions, from everyday HR matters to more complex employment issues.
Whether you’re looking for help with employment agreements, navigating a difficult conversation or supporting your team’s development, knowing where you stand can make the next step clearer.
We’ve brought together answers to some of the questions we’re asked most often about our services and how we can support your business. Every workplace is different, so if you need advice specific to your situation or aren’t sure where to start, get in touch. We’re happy to talk it through.
Explore our frequently asked questions below:

What constitutes a legally compliant restructuring process in New Zealand?
Under New Zealand employment law and the test of justification in section 103A of the Employment Relations Act 2000, a lawful restructuring requires two fundamental elements:
- Substantive Business Justification: The employer must have a genuine, demonstrable business reason for the proposed change (such as financial necessity, efficiency gains, technological changes, downturn in demand, or realigning strategic direction). Redundancy cannot be used to manage underperformance or conduct issues.
- Procedural Fairness: The employer must consult meaningfully before any final decision is made. This includes providing affected employees with an informative consultation document, relevant background information, genuine opportunity to give feedback, and full consideration of that feedback with an open mind before confirming the outcome.
Can we disestablish a role without employee consultation if our business justification is urgent?
No. In New Zealand, consultation is a mandatory statutory requirement, not a courtesy. Failure to consult almost invariably renders any subsequent dismissal or disadvantage unjustified, exposing the employer to personal grievance claims. Even in urgent financial situations, an expedited consultation process must still take place to allow affected staff to comment and propose alternatives.
What is the difference between disestablishing a role and making an employee redundant?
- Disestablishment applies to the position: the employer determines that a specific role, function, or set of duties is no longer required in the organisational structure.
- Redundancy applies to the person: it occurs when an employee’s role has been disestablished and, following consultation and consideration of redeployment, no suitable alternative employment exists, resulting in the termination of employment.
How do we select which employees are affected when reducing numbers in identical roles?
Where multiple employees perform the same role and only some roles are being reduced, employers must use clear, objective, and contestable selection criteria (e.g., skills matrix, relevant experience, qualifications, and past performance records). The selection criteria and weighting must be shared during the consultation process so employees have a fair chance to review and provide feedback prior to scoring.
What redeployment obligations does an employer have?
An employer has an active, positive legal duty to explore reasonable redeployment opportunities across the business (and related entities, where applicable) before proceeding to redundancy. If a vacant position exists for which the affected employee has the capability or could be trained within a reasonable timeframe, it should generally be offered to the affected employee prior to external advertising.
Are employers legally required to pay redundancy compensation?
In New Zealand, there is no statutory right to redundancy compensation unless it is explicitly provided for in the employee’s Individual Employment Agreement (IEA), Multi-Employer/Single-Employer Collective Agreement (MECA/CEA), or company policy. However, employers must always provide the contractual notice period (or payment in lieu, if agreed and permitted by the agreement) alongside statutory entitlements like accrued annual leave.
How can ERS assist during a restructuring or downsizing process?
ERS provides end-to-end guidance to minimize legal exposure, protect workplace morale, and achieve commercial objectives:
- Developing substantive business justifications and restructuring roadmaps.
- Drafting compliant consultation proposals, employee letters, and FAQs.
- Designing objective, contestable selection criteria and matrices.
- Facilitating consultation meetings, analyzing staff submissions, and drafting decision documents.
- Guiding teams through redeployment, notice periods, and post-restructure team rebuilding.
When can collective bargaining be initiated, and who can initiate it?
Under Part 5 of the Employment Relations Act 2000, either a registered union or an employer can initiate collective bargaining:
- Where there is an existing collective agreement:
- A union may initiate bargaining within 60 days prior to the agreement’s expiry date.
- An employer may initiate bargaining within 40 days prior to expiry.
- Where there is NO existing collective agreement in force (a new collective):
- A registered union can initiate bargaining at any time, provided it has members employed by the employer whose work falls within the proposed coverage.
- An employer can only initiate bargaining for a new agreement if there is, or has previously been, an applicable collective agreement in place that covered employees whose work falls within the proposed coverage. An employer cannot initiate bargaining from scratch if no collective agreement has ever applied.
What are the formal requirements for a valid Notice Initiating Bargaining?
Bargaining does not legally begin simply by exchanging drafts, holding informal discussions, or emailing claims. To be legally valid under section 42 of the Employment Relations Act 2000, the initiating party must serve a formal written Notice Initiating Bargaining that explicitly contains:
- Identification of the Parties: The legal name of the union(s) and employer(s) intended to be bound.
- Proposed Coverage Clause: A clear description of the work, occupational categories, and/or employees intended to be covered by the agreement.
- Execution: The notice must be in writing and signed by an authorised representative or advocate of the initiating union or employer.
What rules apply if the union is initiating for a Multi-Employer Collective Agreement (MECA)?
When a union seeks to initiate bargaining that involves more than one employer (a MECA):
- Mandatory Secret Ballot: Under section 44 of the Act, before serving the notice, the union must hold a secret ballot of its members employed by each intended employer party.
- Ballot Result Threshold: The union can only include an employer in the MECA notice if a majority of eligible union members at that specific employer who vote in the ballot vote in favour of initiating multi-employer bargaining.
- Result Certification: The union must confirm in writing in (or alongside) the notice that a secret ballot was properly conducted and passed for each employer named.
What are an employer’s immediate legal duties upon receiving a Notice Initiating Bargaining?
Receipt of a valid notice triggers strict statutory duties and tight compliance deadlines:
- Statutory Employee Notification (Sections 43 & 44):
- The employer must notify all employees whose work falls within the proposed coverage clause (regardless of whether they are union members or on Individual Employment Agreements) that bargaining has been initiated.
- Deadline: Notification must be provided within 10 days if only one employer is named in the notice, or within 15 days if multiple employers are named (a MECA).
- The notice to employees must state the intended parties and the proposed coverage.
- Bargaining Process Agreement (BPA) (Section 32):
- The parties must meet in good faith and make every reasonable endeavour to agree on a structured Bargaining Process Arrangement.
- A BPA sets the ground rules for negotiations, including meeting schedules, communication protocols, representation, claim exchanges, and how information requests will be managed.
- Good Faith Engagement:
- An employer cannot simply ignore or refuse to bargain. The employer must engage actively and constructively, consider and respond to claims, provide relevant non-confidential information, and state reasons for declining any claims.
Can an employer refuse to bargain for a Multi-Employer Collective Agreement (MECA)?
Under current New Zealand employment law, employers cannot simply opt out of or ignore a validly initiated MECA. Employers must sit at the table and engage in good faith bargaining. However:
- Good faith bargaining requires the parties to try to agree, but it does not compel an employer to agree to any specific term or to settle a MECA.
- The law recognises that legitimate business and commercial grounds can justify concluding a Single-Employer Collective Agreement (SECA) rather than signing up to a MECA, provided the employer engages in genuine good faith negotiations.
Can competing or overlapping bargaining notices be consolidated?
Yes. If an employer receives notices initiating bargaining with identical or overlapping coverage from more than one union (or for multiple groups):
- The employer can formally request that the unions consolidate the bargaining into a single process.
- Timeline: The employer must request consolidation within 40 days of receiving the first notice.
- The unions have 30 days to either agree to consolidate or withdraw their notice. If a union fails to respond within 30 days, their notice initiating bargaining is deemed legally withdrawn.
What mandatory clauses must every new collective agreement contain?
Under section 54 of the Employment Relations Act 2000, any collective agreement resulting from bargaining must include:
- Coverage Clause: Explicitly specifying the work and categories of employees covered.
- Plain-Language Dispute Resolution Clause: An explanation of services and procedures for resolving employment relationship problems, including statutory timeframes (such as 90 days for personal grievances, or 12 months for sexual harassment).
- Variation Clause: A provision setting out how the agreement can be amended during its term.
- Expiry Date or Event: A clear expiry date (the maximum term of a collective agreement is 3 years).
- Rates of Wages or Salary: Clear minimum pay rates or transparent mechanisms/formulas explaining how pay is calculated and how it may increase during the term.
- Public Holidays Clause: A provision ensuring compliance with the Holidays Act 2003 (minimum time-and-a-half for working on a public holiday).
- Employee Protection Provision (EPP): Protections for employees in restructuring situations involving sale, transfer, or contracting out.
What is the "No Pass-On" rule, and can terms be extended to non-union staff?
Section 59B of the Employment Relations Act prohibits employers from passing on collectively bargained terms to non-union employees if doing so has the effect or purpose of undermining the collective agreement or union membership. Collective agreements often include a specific “No Pass-On” clause requiring independent negotiations with non-union staff.
How should an employer respond to industrial action (strikes or lockouts)?
Lawful strikes and lockouts can only occur in specific circumstances, such as bargaining for a collective agreement after statutory notice periods have expired and after 40 days from initiation. ERS assists employers in contingency planning, assessing the legality of notices, managing health and safety risks, handling communications, and utilising mediation to resolve deadlocks and achieve sustainable settlements.
How does ERS assist employers facing a new or renewed collective bargaining process?
ERS provides comprehensive strategic and operational collective bargaining support:
- Notice Audits & Strategy: Assessing the legal validity of initiation notices, checking proposed coverage boundaries, and managing mandatory employee notifications within statutory deadlines.
- Bargaining Process Arrangements (BPAs): Drafting robust process agreements to set productive parameters and manage union expectations from day one.
- At-the-Table Representation: Acting as chief negotiator or supporting your leadership team to lead claims and counter-proposals confidently.
- Financial & Cost Modelling: Analysing the true cost of claims (including base rates, allowances, overtime multipliers, and leave liabilities) against sector benchmarks.
- Drafting & Ratification: Drafting clear, dispute-free terms of settlement and ensuring correct codification in the final collective agreement
What is the fundamental difference between poor performance and misconduct?
- Performance (Capability): Relates to an employee’s capability, competence, skill, or aptitude to meet the required standards of their role over time. Underperformance is managed through constructive coaching, clear performance benchmarks, appropriate training, and structured Performance Improvement Plans (PIPs). Disciplinary action cannot be used as a shortcut to bypass a genuine capability process.
- Misconduct (Conduct): Involves an employee’s deliberate, reckless, or negligent actions or behaviour that breach employment obligations, company policies, lawful instructions, or workplace standards. Misconduct is addressed through a formal disciplinary inquiry assessing whether the behaviour occurred and its degree of seriousness.
What is the test of justification under New Zealand law for disciplinary action?
Under section 103A of the Employment Relations Act 2000, any disciplinary action (including formal warnings or dismissal) is evaluated on whether the employer’s actions were what a fair and reasonable employer could have done in all the circumstances at the time. This requires strict adherence to natural justice and procedural fairness:
- Sufficiently investigating the allegations before forming a view.
- Providing the employee with full, clear details of the allegations and all supporting materials.
- Giving the employee a reasonable opportunity to seek advice and be accompanied by a support person or representative.
- Giving the employee a genuine opportunity to respond.
- Genuinely considering the employee’s explanation with an open mind before deciding on any disciplinary outcome.
What constitutes a fair Performance Improvement Plan (PIP)?
A legally compliant capability/performance management process requires:
- Clear Standards: Explicitly identifying where the employee’s performance fails to meet required standards and what specific improvements are necessary.
- Realistic Timeframes: Giving the employee a fair and reasonable period to demonstrate improvement, taking into account the complexity of the role.
- Support and Training: Providing practical guidance, coaching, mentoring, and any necessary training or tools to help the employee succeed.
- Regular Reviews: Scheduling structured review meetings with documented feedback.
- Prior Notice of Consequences: Clearly informing the employee in writing at the outset that failure to meet and sustain the required standards may ultimately result in disciplinary action up to and including termination of employment.
What is the difference between misconduct and serious misconduct?
- Misconduct: Inappropriate behavior, minor insubordination, repeated tardiness, or minor policy breaches. It typically warrants an informal discussion, a written warning, or a final written warning depending on whether prior active warnings exist.
- Serious Misconduct: Conduct that deeply impairs or destroys the trust and confidence essential to the employment relationship (e.g., theft, physical violence, gross insubordination, severe breach of health and safety, intentional falsification of records). If substantiated following a fair process, it may justify summary dismissal without notice.
When is an employer justified in suspending an employee?
Suspension on pay is an interim risk-mitigation measure, not a disciplinary sanction or an indication of guilt. It is only justified where there is a serious, demonstrable risk to the safety of staff or clients, potential tampering with evidence, or significant business disruption that cannot be resolved through alternative measures (such as working from home or reassignment). Except in exceptional emergencies, the employer must propose the suspension, explain the reasons, and give the employee an opportunity to comment before confirming it.
How does ERS assist employers with disciplinary and performance management?
- Advising on the appropriate pathways (distinguishing between conduct and capability) to comply with collective agreements, policies, and statutory obligations.
- Drafting compliant letters of concern, disciplinary invitation letters, performance improvement plans, and outcome letters.
- Supporting or guiding managers through difficult disciplinary meetings and PIP reviews.
- Delivering management training programmes on running fair disciplinary investigations, handling difficult conversations, and executing performance reviews.
What is a formal workplace investigation?
A workplace investigation is an objective, fact-finding process designed to establish what happened regarding a specific workplace complaint, allegation, or incident. The investigator gathers relevant facts, interviews witnesses, reviews physical/electronic records, and makes factual findings on the balance of probabilities. The investigation itself is separate from the employer’s subsequent decision-making regarding disciplinary outcomes.
When is an independent, external workplace investigator required?
An external licensed investigator should be engaged when:
- Seniority and Impartiality: The allegations involve senior leadership, HR personnel, or executives where internal bias or conflicts of interest could be alleged.
- Severity of Allegations: The complaint involves complex, high-risk issues such as bullying, harassment, sexual harassment, or protected disclosures (whistleblowing).
- Capacity and Expertise: Internal HR or operational teams lack the time, specialised interviewing skills, or licensed qualification to conduct a forensic inquiry.
- High Litigation Risk: The matter is likely to be scrutinised by the Employment Relations Authority or Employment Court, requiring an independent inquiry that withstands legal challenge.
What is a "Terms of Reference" and why is it essential?
The Terms of Reference (ToR) is the governing document of an investigation. It defines:
- The precise scope and specific allegations to be examined (preventing scope creep).
- The identity of the investigator and their role as an independent fact-finder.
- The investigative methodology and confidentiality protocols.
- The rights of the complainant, respondent, and witnesses (including representation and access to information).
- The format of the final report (whether it contains factual findings only or recommendations for the employer).
What are the natural justice requirements for respondents and witnesses during an investigation?
- Full Information: The respondent must be given the specific details of the allegations against them and copies of relevant documents and evidence relied upon, in sufficient detail to allow a comprehensive response.
- Right to Representation: Participants are entitled to bring an independent representative, union delegate, lawyer, or support person to all investigative meetings.
- Reasonable Timeframes: Parties must be given adequate time to prepare for interviews and review draft statements or preliminary findings.
- Confidentiality: The process must be kept confidential to the participants to protect reputation, evidence integrity, and privacy.
- Right of Reply: The respondent must have an opportunity to comment on any contradictory witness evidence or adverse preliminary conclusions before the final report is completed.
What is the standard of proof used in a workplace investigation?
Workplace investigations use the civil standard of proof: the balance of probabilities (i.e., whether it is more likely than not that the alleged conduct occurred), rather than the criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt. The investigator must base their conclusions on reliable, credible evidence and logical inferences rather than suspicion or conjecture.
What are ERS’s credentials and capabilities in conducting investigations?
- Licensed Investigators: ERS is formally licensed to undertake private workplace investigations in New Zealand.
- Specialist Subject-Matter Expertise: ERS has nearly a decade of experience conducting sensitive investigations into sexual harassment, systemic workplace bullying, serious health and safety breaches, fraud, and executive misconduct across commercial, public, and not-for-profit sectors.
- Clear, Evidence-Based Reports: ERS delivers comprehensive, defensible investigative reports that enable employers to make informed decisions that mitigate legal and reputational risk.
How long does an employee have to raise a Personal Grievance (PG)?
Under the Employment Relations Act 2000, employees must formally raise a personal grievance within 90 calendar days from the date the action occurred or came to their notice. For allegations of sexual harassment, the statutory timeframe is 12 months.
What should an employer do immediately upon receiving a PG letter?
- Acknowledge receipt promptly in writing without admitting liability.
- Note the statutory timeframes and check whether the grievance was raised within the allowable period.
- Review the employee’s file, contracts, relevant correspondence, and file notes.
- Seek early specialist advice before providing a detailed written rebuttal or entering into discussions.
- Prepare for confidential mediation through the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE) or engage in private settlement discussions (e.g., section 123/149 record of settlement).
How does ERS support employers facing grievances or disputes?
ERS evaluates legal exposure against commercial realities. We draft formal responses, formulate pragmatic settlement strategies, represent employers during MBIE Mediation and Employment Relations Authority hearings, and draft binding, full-and-final Records of Settlement to eliminate future risk.
What industries does ERS work with?
ERS provides specialist HR and employment relations support across diverse private, public, and non-profit sectors throughout New Zealand, including FMCG, Food Processing, Manufacturing, Logistics, Supply Chain & Warehousing, Transport, Marine, Health & Aged Care, Education, Local and Central Government, Construction, and NGOs.
Does ERS offer ongoing support or only one-off project advisory?
We offer both:
- Partnering & Retainer Models: Functioning as your retained People & Performance / ER team, providing proactive advisory, compliance reviews, and day-to-day HR support.
- Specialist / One-Off Support: Direct engagement for complex collective bargaining rounds, formal workplace investigations, high-risk restructures, executive mediations, or Employment Relations Authority disputes.
- Leadership & Management Training: Practical workshops covering performance reviews, conducting investigations, managing change, and resilience.
Do You Need Clear Advice for Complex Workplace Issues?
If you want to be supported by the best advisor for your case, we’d like to hear from you!
About ERS
ERS provides trusted, senior employment relations advice and representation for employers and organisations across Auckland and throughout New Zealand.
Menu Links

